Bản án 186Tranh chấp hợp đồng vay tài sản

$ lO^,tN NUAN nAu KIiu vuc,r - cA nrau Ilin rin s6: 1862026/DS-S|' Ngdy l2-5-2026 V/v tranh ch6p hqp d6ng vay tii srin cgNc HOA XA rrQr clru NGHiA Vilt.r.NA\{ DQc If p - -I'rr do - H4nh phrlc NIIAN DANIT NtI6c ceNG lroA xA Hgr cHO NGHiA vrET NAM ToA AN NrrAN DAN Krru vUC 4 _ cA MAU - Thtitrlt phAn II6i ilittg .rdt -vti.so.thfrm gint ci: fhaiLm phan - Cht) toa phi€n Ctic ttoi tham nhan cltin: tdn: BitFluli,nh Ngoc Mai 0rrg Nguy[:rr Van I Iiirr Ong Nguv6n I lodng Anh - Thu'k.i phiAn k\u: I3i, t Ii'l'hi Diem My la rhu ki. .t-od 4 Cd Mau. 6n nhdn d6n khu vLr.c Ct l2 th6ng S.ndm 2026, tai trg s<r Toa 6n nh6n d6n khu vr,rc 4 _ Cd Mau ...,. ]sdy, xer xu so rhiim cong khai vp 6n d6n su thu. l1i s(): 292/2O26ITLST_DS ngriy 0 t thdng 4 nim 2026.vd vi09 ch6p hcro O'On! ,ay tai ,an; ifr.o qry., iinn Au, vu 6n ra x6t xu s6: 2o6r2o26reExxsr-bs ,giy io th6ng 4 na^ioza gii,, .a. duong su: -.ira1h - Nguvan.dcrn Bd Ng6'rhi Le, sinh ndm 1965; 56 cccD: 096165007623; Dia chi cu tr0: Ap 'f6n Long B, x6 DAm Doi, tinh Ca fr4", fritU;A,I-'" - Bi dnn: Bd Nguy6n Thu Hoa, sinh n6m 196g; Dia chi cu trir: Ap l, xi D6nr Doi, tinh Cd Mau (ving mdt). NOI DUNG VIJ AN: * 'l'heo don khoi ki6n cua bd L6 vd loi trinh bdy cfra bd L6 trong qu6 rrinh girii quytit vq 6n th6 hi€n: . hen sd thanh to6n sau vii ngdy, khi mu,n ti6n bd Hoa nhi6n, bd Hoa chi hira hen md kh6ng thuc hi€n. Nay ba Lc"yeu nghia vu 116 cho bd s6 ti6n le 3 I .000.000 dbng. vdo ngiry t6l0z/2026 bd Hoa c6 h6i muon bd s6 ti6n 3 r.000.000 d6ng, hfta ilsiri;h;tilJin. -r-ry fa'Hou .o "au "6 ' i^u,i .9*. bd Nguy6n Thu FIoa: D6 duoc Toa rin t6ng dat hqp 16 c6c vdn bdn t6 tung de bret duoc yeu c6u khoi ki€n crla bd L6 nhung bd Hoa kh6ng c6 1; kien d6i l voi ydu cAu khoi kign cta bi L€ vd kh6ng tharn gia hoa gi6i' xet xu' NrrAN DINH CUA't'OA AN: .t.hu

[1]VCthrlqrct6tqng:BdNg6Th!LEc6d.onxinx6txirv6ngm4t;bdNguyen tda lAn thu hai nhtmg virng mflt Hoa d6 dugc fdu an-ir[u tQi tham gia phi€n kl.rong c6 li do. Do d6, H;iad*et *o""att cu.Ei6u 228 cua BQ luit t6 tsng ddn ;;;?;; v'ing mqt c6c duong su"ld pht hop va dirng quv dinh cua phdp luflt' giAV thoa t'huan tr6n' M[t I!6::.ba

[2] VC nQi dung: Bir Ld cho ring bd Hoa c6. h6i musn bd s6 ti0n 3l'000'000 .O *uy,tu, O*qc th6"hiQn qua gi6v thoa thuin ngdy 1610212026' dong ld thgc t€ Theo giSy th6a thu{n tnaf,ie" Ua Hoa c6 mugn tuu Ua r-e to tion :l'ooo'000 d6ng' I{oa di dugc bd Hoa vd bi L€ cirng k:i #n il;';;;6,.; d" ht'p19 Ja" 'a" uu"n ro tsng nhung khdng co 1i^ kien gi vc vou cau khoi kien cira bd LC ,e ;;;; ;il; ei" t'""" gi6i,xet xi n6n 9?'9"9: xcm lzr tinh tiet, su kiQn kh6ng pf'lai .f"^E 'i"t' ittt" q'y Ainn t4i khoAn 2 Di6u 92 ctia Il0 luAt Tt c6c lap luf,n n6u tr6n, Hqi d6ng x6t xu c6 co sd ch6p nh6n y6u ciu khoi kiQn c0a bd L6. Buqc b;H";;; nghia vu tra cho bd L€ s6 ti6n 31'000'000 d6ng'

[3] VO 6n phi.d6n sq: B2r L€ kh6ngptai.ch!u' Bd Hoa ph6i chiu 1'550'000 to tgng dAn sY. 'ao aong i:i.ooo.ooo d6ng x 5Yo:1'550'000 d6ng)' h cdc ld trAn, QUYfTDINH: C6n cu vdo khoirn 2 Di6u 92;DiAu 147' Di6u 228 vd Diiu 273 cua B0 luat t6 c1'vet s6 tqng ddn su; Di6u 4o3 crl;n61'at oan 'yj $oan 326t2or6NBTVQH14 "iii zoiniol6 cua Uv ban thudng vu Qu6c hQi quv dinh ;a;";; ;;;ian, eiam, ir-tu' nOp, qudn l1i va su dqng 6n phi vd lQ phi 1'oa 6n; 16 ,NgT 2 Dii:u $\ Tuy€n xu:

1. Chap nh{n y6u ciu khoi kiQn cta.Ualgg Thi Le' BuQc bd Nguv6n-l'hu Ua NgO ff i LC sd ti6n 31 '000'000 diing (ba rnuoi m6t triQu Uoa cO ngtria ,\, tia d6ng). "ho K6 tu ngdy bd Ld c6 dcrn y€u ciu thi hdnh 6n' n6u.bd Ho1-3na1 thi hirnh r.rroan iieoi.cr", it i ha.,g ;;; # H9" cdn. ph6i chiu th6m khoin ldi suat cl1{m thi hdnh theo muc lli *at .f i'"'tf.ruc hiQn nghia vq dugc quy d[nh t4i khoAn 2 Di6u 468 cira B0 luat DAn sq tuong irng s6 tiin vd thoi gian ch{m thi hdnh'

2. V6 6n phi din sq: Bir Ng6 Thi L6 kh6ng phai chlu; BA Nguydn Thu I loa phai chlu 1.550.000 d6ng' Trucrng hqp bAn 6n, quy6t dinh duqc thi hdnh theo quy dinh tai Di6u 2 LLr6t I'hi hdnh 6n ddn sp thi ng,rOi'Jlrqt tt'i nann dn d6n su nguoi phii thi hirnh'6n dAn slr c6 qrva, ir-ro"-,fr,ian tniiunr'tJn, quyin y6u ciu thi hanh 6n' tu nguyQn thi h2rnh 6n hodc i 3 bi cudngch'5thi hanh6ntheoquydinhtqicricDi6u 6,7,7a,7bvit9luatThi hdnh6n thi hdnh iin duoc tiruc hi6n th;;ri airr, iai oia, ,o lrai'irr, nu",,, d6n su; thoi hi€u 6n d6n sy. . ?"onq sr,r c6 quy6n.kh6ng crio trong thoi hgn l5 ngriy kti tu ngdy rrh6n duoc -1-" '- "a"J n! rs 116<rlrrr(r bdn 6n hodc bdn 6n hoac t6ngdAi hSp l€. ,\iti ttltQn: - Viirr lii0rn siit nlril clan khtr r Lrc .l . (.a Nlarr: - Irhi\rg'l hi harrh t'rn cliin su.kjtLr vLlc 4 Ci Mau: - ( iic drrong su: - I rru ltri so ru :in: - l- trrr rirn pht)nt. TM. IIOI DONG XET XU'S('.r.IIAM .I'IIAN'I -cHUTQA PrrIl]N 1'O,,\ n h Ng<2c Mai (1