Bản án 35Bản án 35

lrf roa aN NnAx nAN riNn euANc NrNH Bin 6n s6:3 5 12026/I{5-ST Ngdy:20/4/2026 cQNG rroA xA ugl cHO DQc lgp - Tp do - NGIIIA VIET NAM If4nh phric ToA eN euauc rvuffic ,, BAN AN I}A CO HIEU ITIC NHAN DANH NG HoA xA ngr cHE NGHIA vrET NAM roa AN NHAN oAN riNH quANc NrNH - Thdnh phAn HQi it6ng xdt xtb so thdm gim cd: Thiim phdn -_C_ni ea p"hren tda; phamff8"e firai Thiim phdn:, Bd Nguy8" ffrr>, Hdne Cdc Hli thtim nhdn ddn: Qrg p"5 Xu6n Hodi Ong Nguy6n Xu6n Ti6n phi€n "r* "eav tda: Bit 'er?,il#iIffi - rhu ky rda 6n nh6n d6n tinh arars-.ffi; .rtv **,ra,?fll 1;',;!'#r#x:::rydn ddn rinh Qudng Ninh tham gia phian tda: Bit Ngdy 20 thang4 ndm 2o26,tai tr.u so Tda rin n]rin d6n tinh Qu6ng Ninh, Tda 6n nhen den rinh a:qg Ninh *o phien tou *ei,.,i rr'r1i1 c6ng hpi * 6n hinh ss thp lv s6: 0B/2026/TLlsa-t! ,eey:6 thring ot namioz6 !!eo euy6t dinh dua vs 6n ra x6t xri so zttzozozqpxxsi-iri ,ga),." l;;,, 2026;ddi voi'bi crio: t/Bf c6o: Nguv6n Tu6n Ninh, sinh ziiii983, t?i tinh eu6ng Ninh. Noi cu rrr: t6 4, khu *;*.*, ,, ph"-;; y6r.q;i il duan! Nrrrr, nehjep: kh6ng; trinh d0 hec v6n: 1 z/r2;dani6c: *rrr; si6i r,*, ffi t6n gi6o: kh6re; qu6c tich: viQt "irra Nam; doan th6: Eurg vi6n thuQc o*g"uo prr"*g ii: sg da bi xojt t6n trong danh s6ch Eang vi6n; ro' 6ng Nguv.n yar.1err, riiIi"icrl."lpd Nguv61 Thi Hg; vo rd Phpm Thu Hucmg; c6 0icor'; iid".ar, ticn *,'m,org.-oiBi cao-biuir r*y n6 ngdy .sx oa; nil M6y _- rrai ,,, va, phdng ru6t lam giam tpi Traitpm gg" cong uir_tinh euang Ninh (c6 mat). Minh Tri, thuQc Doan lu6t su tintr quung Ninh (C6 m6t). ,#,}*tt i,l#l#i+ffiT#nhndm tel4;dia chi: t6 r8c, khu e, phucrng vdng ,fr'#-Tffi,##Hi]t'u,n 1e86; dia chi: t6 164, khu 54, phucrng U6ng "t ve"s'ffi,ffiilT,ffit&HJffie81; dia chi: t6 2oA,khu B6c Son 4, phucmg uu,!ii,ffii#[-^ffi',i#X;fl ndm re78; dia chi: t6 208, khu 6, phuong - Ludt su bdo chria cho bi Lai, 10/6/2025, hiQn 2/Bihai: 1 Bi, tinh Quang Ninh (Vdng mat). 2.5. Anh N 4ua" Lgi, sinh ndm 1973; dia chi: t6 20A, khu 6, phuong UOng 2.6. AnhNg;yd NgI; rfii", sinh nlm 1985; dia chi: tO 3, khu 7, phuong Ving Danh, tinh Quang Ninh ryAr-rg m{t)' 2.7. AnhBrii-Vanbnt., sinh n[m 1982; dia chi: t.5 338, khu Phri Thanh Tdy, phucrng U6ng Bi, tinh Quing Ninh ryAng mit)' NQI DUNG V8 AN: Theo citc titiliQu c6 trong h6 so vp 6n vd diSn bii5n tpi phi0n tda, nQi dung vp * -- 6n dugc tom tit nhu sau: **"r4" i"a" Ninh lir c6ng chric dia chinh - xdylqg vi mgi oYTg, ldm viQc tai UBND prr"t g Y6n Thanh (tu nlm 2015-2021) vd UBND phuong B6c Scvn (tu n6m ZO21-ZOZ3) nt ld phudrng UOrrg Bi vd phudng Y*g Danh tinh Qu6ng Ninh.NhiQm vg cria Ninh ta quan ly nh+ nu6c vd,c6ng tdc ddt dai, tham muu .cho UBND phucrng a& giay chuns nhan quvdn su dpng aat piti x6t duyqt nguon ;;'e6;t;;;i, "ap i*-ii,'iiiTisifiy CNeSiD tr6n rtia bdn c6c phudng, tii5p nhan vd giii quv6t h6 sonlnn chinh tai bo pf,a" mQt ctra 1i6n th6ng ttr trung t6m hdnh chinh c6ng chuyen v€, tiisp nhan vir tr6 ki5t qui vi php tr6ch linh v.uc m6itruong..... ' Tiong thoi gian Ninh c6ng tdc tqi c6c dcrn vf tr6n, mQt s6. ngudi d6n tr6n dia ban dA nhd Ninh"gi,ip ldm thir tu. .ap LiaV CNqSDD, chuy6n.cl6i mrlc dich st dung ^cNespo. Thdidiil niry, do dalg cAn ti6nchi ti6u cdnhdn,trh ;il ,h*a; rrr"q,rg ##i;;; ,G" 6o tr6n m?ng xE hQi, nen m{c.dtr n6in ro c6c th6ng tin vd c6c thtra ;4, ;, *.;5^"g"d't t lr6G dt E1ctr tiii ai giilycNQSDE nhms \ry u-* dYu'? th6ng tin gian a5i fu cO th5hm.dusc c6c thir quc c6p, qai g1ry CNQSDD tro-1c mlt s1 *drrg nd At diQr kiQ"n cap giSy CNQSDE nhmg l{inh kfi6ng gui hO so d6n chc co h9 chuyen ti€n dC ldm thu tuc' quan c6 tham q"yil g[led,fu ,ut nhr-g van y6u Sau khi nhan d";;;t;, Nt"h khgng.trqrJtrien cac thtr tsc dd cdp, aoi qilv cJ{gsDP -su $ung trq ng, chi ti6u c5 nh61vd chuy6n .[" rrr*a'chii5m doptiodn b0 so ti6n d6 ki;;e" ac, ,nia" tdi khoin kh6c nhau ae aAu tu tidn 6o v6i c6c nOi dung chuy6n mroan dugc ghi chri lir "khang 07", hanh vi phpm tQi cira Ninh cp th6 nhu sau: Vu thri rhd ;; bairri iirr,, sinh nirn- 1 95 5, tru tai : ti5 1 8C, t<tru l,,nhlT,g B1' Son, thdnh ph$ U6ng Bi (nay ld phudng Vdng Danh, ttnh Quang Ninh) c6 thria d6t khaihoang digr, tich fhoang SOOtnZ t?i t6 18C, khu 9, phudng Vang Dj{, tinhQuang Ninh, chui dugc cdp gi6y-CNQSDD. Khoing giira ndm 2022, be Tinh c6 nhu cau 'do^j.'.Affiav cNqbip-.tto thira ddt trcn non c6 trao ooi voi con g6i ld chi vf, Thi Bich HOne. su, io];iHd;; o-a tt- a6iuoi o.,g ri6u Vdn DOng f.* tt ba rinh) di5 li6n hQ v6i Nguy[n TuAn Ninh - ltc niry dang ld c6n bQ d1a chinh qhuong Bdc Son iO;a ili ;;hii ,of.* ei6y cNesDD. Ninh b6o chi HOng y6u cdu dua cho Ninh 200.000.000 d6ng dc u* tt ri tur. Ngdy o2llol2o22, ngiry 211.t112022 vd 1211212022, ;iild;;aa 4"" cho chi Ditre qiriors ruoi 1.'n iau-.iri uong;.va 6ns D6ng 03 pn Ninh vd dua ,6"* 15 iio" t+S.000.000 dOng rOi cfri.iuoi di cung_9lg P6"9.d61e6P toan uO so tien niry cho Ninh. lltrir"g lAn nh0n tiAn Ninh c16u vi6t giAy bi6n nhan dudi 2 26p 9Au _a*g sri dung Ia dat san xu6L i ddt tr6ng cav tiu ndm. wND oi ti,i1ti, ia lfi,,ilba chdmg,nn ; '] l t \ "a 21t "nrr ong E6ng.g:o hirh erh'Nirh;#*iai uic" nhqn cho 6ng D6ng. hinh thric vav tidn, hen d6n hc,.t^hTq 3 1* 2023 sE tr6 lai tidn. sau khi nhfln tidn, [tflff chi6m do?t todn b0 s6 tien tzs.oO0.aodarg cria ,r,i vu Tlri Bich H6ng, chi lpp co quan dizu ra 0J.q6v bi6n nhan rong cr6 Nguy6n Tujn Ninh xric nh6n 03 l6n nnan ti6n cua 6ng E6ng.vd .rri."rrJ rrro tbn; o1 i-rig uen tong chria 03 fite videq ki6m tra c6 hinh anh rirrr, "gaiffi,1r:;.04zu;a;*;;;; qm thi t.u. c6p gi6v cNesDD rlro ba Tinh Tpi ban ttlt tu4n ei6m aror, 19 *rlo,gurE# r ut^o)s,.ru nio,g g mrat ninr, s'u c6ng an ffi Quang Ninh t<tit tuan: riet ,fi W mofg t€n Npydn rhin Ninh 6 tdi iXXXf affi rs,,b ni* a-di*-**r';; rihr,,ia, chir tsrd tdi rieu mdu so sanh T4r vdn ban s6 127ruBND ngiry 27/6/2023, cinuBND phuong nac son x6c dinh ua od Thi Ti'nh c6 thria o6t urui t oang ta dia chi o* ,r,.iu so t:o di-enlrch:t t,3,,2. ticn rq'e ctang r6ng rntt"av uu"r, aa" c5n cr ban ;q T;iT# ST.,[ aat ctnphuong Bdc son ndn2o2l-20?0, uir